I grew up watching football. I wasn’t young enough to know about John Madden’s career as a coach. To me, he was just the crazy guy who was on football games on Thanksgiving and for the Super Bowl at times. Oh, and there was also Madden NFL on every video game console imaginable. My first hardcore football fan memory was of Madden calling the 2006 Super Bowl with Al Michaels; it was the second-to-last Super Bowl that he would ever call. So for a movie to come out that goes through Madden’s life as a coach seems like a pretty smart idea. However, Madden from director David O. Russell isn’t the standard biopic of a famous person. It starts off right from the rip with a message that “some of this happened, some of it didn’t”.
Honestly, that’s an incredibly refreshing way to do a biopic. If this was a standard movie about the life of John Madden, it would be far too long. He has basically three career arcs, and that doesn’t count his time before coaching. If you thought MIchael was long and needed more parts, the straight-laced Madden biopic might dwarf that. Instead, they take a more unrealistic route that adds in the relationship between Madden (played by Nicolas Cage) and Al Davis (played by Christian Bale). There are some things that feel a bit hamfisted throughout, but the performances here, for the most part, are what drive the movie.
At the heart of this, the movie falls directly on the shoulders of Nicolas Cage. If his performance didn’t work, the movie didn’t work. Luckily for all of us football fans, Cage is smashing as John Madden.

So the film takes a bit of an abridged look at John Madden’s life, we start off in the thick of his coaching career for the AFC Championship game against the Pittsburgh Steelers in 1976 and the Super Bowl in 1977 against the Vikings. What normally seems like an ending moment is laid bare in the beginning. The tone of the movie is laid bare right at the beginning as well with Madden yelling at players for being late rather than smoking dope in their cars. Christian Bale’s performance as Al Davis is an all-timer right away as well. For those who don’t know what Al Davis was like, he was the embodiment of the Raiders’ mantra “commitment to excellence”. All he wanted was to win and didn’t care what it cost to do it. You can see this throughout the film.
While there isn’t really an antagonist in the film, the forces going against John are more his relationships and how his work affects them; Al Davis works as a friendly antagonist or a foil to Madden. It was like that in real life with the two men being best of friends and coming together for one of the greatest coach-owner runs in league history. Kathryn Hahn plays Virginia Madden, and her performance more than hammers home that this is not the normal biopic. She’s seemingly always on edge, and the romance/tension between her and John is always played off for laughs more than drama.
The film only reaches a place of earnestness right at the end, in the epilogue about how Madden’s career has come together, and he’s truly reached that place of “football valhalla” as Al Davis calls it. Other than that, everything sort of floats by, but in a strangely entertaining way.

Madden almost feels like the greatest hits of John Madden’s life, but remixed almost. You get the start of the Madden NFL game with Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney) trying to get Madden to put his name on it. This section feels more like a music video or a dream than anything else. There are former NFL player cameos here, and they make explaining how a video game must have sounded to Madden in 1994. Gibberish. There’s a lot of talk about bits and bytes and whatever else video games are made of, and were made of in 1994. Then there’s the big reveal that the game can only do 7-on-7, which sends Madden off the edge. This section of the film was the toughest for me, because it was so strange.
The relationship and performances from Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale are what make this movie, though. They both step right into their roles, with both of them not becoming completely unrecognizable but getting pretty close. But this movie wasn’t going for a straight biopic, so it really benefits the movie overall. Sienna Miller plays Carol Davis, Al’s wife, and she might be the most unrecognizable person in the movie. She steps up her game in the role and does a great job acting alongside the three other leads. The only real throwaway performance in the film is Shane Gillis as Madden’s neighbor. It feels like the role was tacked onto the film for him and could be taken out, and it wouldn’t affect the film in the slightest.

Overall, on its face, Madden really should not work as a film. It doesn’t have an antagonist; it plays off more like a music video/parody, almost, and yet it arrives at a place that is ultimately earnest and nostalgic. John Madden was the voice of a generation of football and continues to have a legacy to this day with the Madden NFL video game. Armed with some excellent performances, David O. Russell has constructed a fever dream of a biopic. It is a fever dream that ends up as a dream come true for football fans because of how damn entertaining the whole thing is, though. It is the movie equivalent of a celebratory fist pump after winning a championship.
Anyone who listened to Madden throughout his career can get a kick out of this. Nicolas Cage embodies the man behind so many football fans in John Madden and we’re all better for it.
Madden releases on November 18th, 2026.
For more Reviews, make sure to check back to That Hollywood Show.
Reviews